Thumb Sucking and Pacifier Use: When to be Concerned & How it Affects Teeth

It’s one of the most natural things in the world for a baby or toddler. That little thumb goes in the mouth, or they find their pacifier, and suddenly, the world is okay. It’s self-soothing at its finest, and honestly, it can be a lifesaver for parents here in Swift Current who are just trying to get through a long winter afternoon or a fussy bedtime.

 

But if you’re a parent starting to think about pediatric dental care for your little one, you’ve probably wondered: When does this go from being a cute, helpful habit to something we need to worry about?

 

It’s a question we get a lot here at Alpine Dental Clinic, and the answer isn’t always black and white. So, let’s break it down a little.

The Early Years: Mostly Fine

For infants and very young toddlers, thumb sucking and pacifier use are completely normal. It satisfies their natural sucking reflex and helps them feel secure. At this stage, it’s really not a dental issue. The main concerns for parents are usually more practical, like the dreaded middle-of-the-night pacifier hunt, or trying to keep that favorite soother clean.

When Do We Start Paying Attention?

The general guideline we use is to start paying closer attention around age three, and to start thinking seriously about gently encouraging them to stop by age four. The reason for this timeline comes down to how their little mouths are growing.

 Before the permanent teeth start to come in (usually around age six), the mouth and jaw are still very moldable. Prolonged, frequent, and vigorous sucking after the baby teeth are all in place can start to cause changes.

mother putting soother in baby's mouth

How It Can Affect Their Teeth

This is the part about thumb sucking and pacifier use that parents are most curious about. So, how does it affect their teeth?

If the habit continues past the toddler years, the pressure from the thumb or pacifier can start to push the front baby teeth forward or prevent the upper and lower teeth from meeting properly. You might notice:

  • An open bite: This is when the front teeth don’t touch when the mouth is closed, even if the back teeth are biting together. It creates a little gap, often shaped like the thumb or pacifier.
  • Protruding front teeth: The upper front teeth may be angled outwards towards the lip.
  • Changes to the roof of the mouth: The constant pressure can sometimes narrow the roof of the mouth (the palate).

The good news is that for many kids, if the habit is stopped before the permanent front teeth come in, these changes can often correct themselves naturally. Their little mouths are amazing like that.

Tips for Gently Breaking the Habit

So, you’re getting to that age where you’re starting to think, “Okay, maybe it’s time.” How do you even begin? Forcing a child to stop something that brings them so much comfort rarely works. A gentler approach is usually way more successful. Here are a few things that have worked for other families we’ve seen:

Focus on the “why,” not the “what.” Instead of just saying “stop,” you can explain it in simple terms. “We’re helping your teeth get strong so they can chew all your favorite foods!” You can make it about helping their teeth, not about taking away their comfort.

Use positive reinforcement. A sticker chart can be magic. For every day (or nap/bedtime) they don’t suck their thumb, they get a sticker. After a certain number of stickers, they get a small reward, like a trip to the park or a new book.

toddler with fingers in his mouth

Identify their triggers. Is it when they’re tired? Bored? Watching TV? If you can identify when they’re most likely to do it, you can sometimes redirect them. Give them a small toy to hold during TV time, or offer extra cuddles when they’re tired.

Make it a special occasion. Some families have success with a “pacifier fairy” or a “thumb fairy” who comes to take the pacifier/thumb away and leaves a small gift. It makes the child an active participant in letting it go.

For pacifiers, you can physically alter it. Sometimes, if you gradually snip a tiny bit off the tip each day (making sure it’s still safe, of course!), it becomes less satisfying to suck on and the child loses interest on their own.

When to Get Your Dentist Involved

If you’re trying to break the habit and it’s just not working, or if your child is a bit older (school-age) and still sucking, definitely give us a shout here at Alpine Dental Clinic. There are appliances we can sometimes use that make it physically difficult or less pleasurable to suck the thumb, but that’s usually a last resort.

The most important thing is not to stress too much. You’re doing a great job. Most children give up these habits on their own. And if they need a little help, we’re right here in Swift Current to help you and your little one through it, with a focus on gentle, positive pediatric dental care. We can take a look at their teeth, reassure you about what you’re seeing, and come up with a plan together if we need one.

child getting her teeth checked
model of teeth at alpine dental clinic

Talk To Us About Your Child's Dental Care - Alpine Dental Clinic

If you have any concerns about your child’s dental development or their sucking habit, don’t hesitate to book an appointment. We’re always happy to chat and take a peek at those little smiles.

Contact Us Today!

Alpine Dental Logo

Book An Appointment